If you have been present on social media (or conscious of the media) over the past year and a half, you have probably heard the term 'defund the police' thrown around. It has been a hot topic discussion that does not seem to have the simplest of solutions. So, what exactly does defund the police mean? I would like to examine different talking points and see if there is any way to make everyone happy?
I found this infographic helpful for a quick summary of reforming, defunding, and abolishing the police. (Feel free to come back to this infographic throughout the post!)
To begin, what do abolitionist mean when they say 'abolish the police?' Quite literally to abolish the police. According to the opinion piece by Mariame Kaba, the basis of this reason is because the policing system is inherently problematic. Ultimately, to reduce violence that is inflicted on the public by the police, is to "reduce contact between the public and the police." In place of the police and patrolling officers would be groups comprised of communities. To make this possible is not to close down the police departments, but to make them obsolete. The abolitionists want to reform the entire idea of policing from an organization to citizens policing each other within their own communities.

There are pros and cons to this ideology. I believe that a a community policing itself would hinder an "us vs them" thought process, and allow adequate representation amongst the diverse communities throughout America. However, this would be difficult to achieve in large cities or places with various population densities.
Moving more towards the right (but not quite the center), we have the argument to 'defund the police.' This argument is based on reallocating money given to the police to different governmentally funded programs. For example, place more money into public schools/education, mental health services, and other programs that may uplift the community so the residents do not look towards crime as a way for survival.

As with any argument, this one also has its pros and cons. The pros here would be a building up of a community. Many of the problems in low income communities derive from underfunding in important areas and aspects of community member's lives. Attention to affordable housing, education, mental health services could create spaces where there is less crime. There would be no need for crime for survival, and ample resources to call for different needs. For example, when a community member is experiencing a mental health crisis there will be people better trained to help, and this will lead to less misconduct and police brutality. Yet, there are cons to 'defund the police.' The entire policing system, police tools, weapons and technology, and training is expensive. With the need to keep up to date with technology, this is costly and needed in the policing sector. So when budget cuts come around it is likely that departments with cut community outreach programs first. These are not 'needed' and will be the first on the chopping block. Yet, these programs are important in creating healthy relationships between the community and the officers.
The last of the changes urged by citizens is police reform. While this is seemingly an umbrella term, for the purpose of this blog I want to focus on the police reform that is just shy of defunding the police. Police reform include better training, stopping harmful restraint tactics, and holding police officers accountable for misconduct. This would require more funds to go towards policing for better training by departments, and requires transparency from police. These measures would build trust between citizens and police.

And of course there are pros AND cons to this! Pros seem like it should go without saying, right? More transparency, better trained personnel, and stopping harmful/dangerous tactics for times when they are not needed. So, what are the cons? Major cons that are listed in the first infographic is that this does not truly help communities in need. Reforming the police does not dive deeper into the conversation of why problematic events happen to marginalized groups of people. Some people do not believe that reform will help at all, as historically it has not. Ultimately, it does not alleviate crime that is happening, but rather it is a better way to combat it with less harm.
To revisit my question, is there any everyone happy? No, of course not. So, what do I think? I am glad you asked. I believe we need to strive to reach somewhere in between reform and defunding. To start, officers that are involved in misconduct MUST be held accountable and efforts to show transparency. Next, there needs to be a requirement for higher education. Statistically, police officers who have college education are more open-minded and more humanitarian. Those who obtain higher education experience more diversity, and courses focus on critical thinking. This would not place the burden of more training, and lack of funding for training, on departments. I also think that some shift in allocation of funding go towards building a stronger and healthier community. This would create an environment where community member are invested in their home. Which can be coupled with higher recruitment of diverse officers, and to see representation would hinder an 'us against them' mentality from each side.
Personally, I do not think this is a quick fix situation. However, if we take 'baby steps' (while holding officers accountable for misconduct) it can be a situation that is fixable.
References:
Introduction to Policing 4th edition- Steven Cox, David Massey, Connie M. Koski, and Brian D. Fitch
The ‘Defund the Police’ slogan for the Black Lives Matter movement was not the solution to combat the police violence problem. The solution to the problem of police violence is to abolish the second amendment and get guns off the streets. We are living in a gun violence epidemic, where everyday citizens can carry weapons on them. Police officers would not need to carry weapons if normal citizens did not carry them either. Policing also needs to be reformed. More and more police officers should at least have a two year college degree, and a lot more training. However, this means that police would actually need more funding.
ReplyDeleteI really appreciate the time and attention you took to differentiate and educate your viewers on some really serious, yet, important topics regarding policing in America. I think slogans like "Abolish the Police", "Defund the Police" are meant to capture the attention of a large audience, and they succeeded in a big way. Your point of a world where "everyone is happy" is exactly as you said, not attainable. But that's just how living in a society where all kinds of people live has to function to promote both safety and freedom. Really great post!
ReplyDeleteI really like this blog! I think it properly educates the reader on the full background of the slogan "defund the police" that has been circulating constantly in recent years. I think that while many people think that it is a drastic measure to take, the pressing of this slogan causes people to look at what is currently going on in the United States and think about how we may reform the police. So while "defund" may seem radicalized to some, it allows a "halfway point" for people to agree upon.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed the blog and how you took the time to explain each definition. These slogans have become popular recently due to the corrupt cops that have done their job. Reform and defunding should be done in order to try and combat this corruption. What stuck with me the most was that you also explained all the pros and cons rather than showing bias. Each definition had good things and not so good things about it. I believe that money should be spread to other services like education and medical services. The police force also needs to be reformed as well in order to try and stop rogue cops. Like you said, the process is slow but I believe it will change eventually. Great job!
ReplyDelete