As a previous fan of Law and Order (SUV specifically), I have found it interesting that the tropes of police we see on television are some what divorced from how we see police in the news. I also wanted to shy away from major media outlets/ social media and dive into other forms of media, in this case television.
This trope would switch after Hollywood came under scrutiny with scandals of big players being convicted of tax evasion, manslaughter, and rape. By the 1920's, Hollywood began building a relationship with the LAPD. This relationship was essential, and would be a major cause for the shift in how the police were portrayed in movies and television.
So, where to begin with police on television? I feel it is important to begin, well, at the beginning. All the way back to the first portrayal of police in Hollywood. In the 1920's police were viewed as dimwitted and the butt of the joke. As seen below, Charlie Chaplin featured police in a few movies, would out smart them, and ultimately come down to a chase where he would comically out run them.
This trope would switch after Hollywood came under scrutiny with scandals of big players being convicted of tax evasion, manslaughter, and rape. By the 1920's, Hollywood began building a relationship with the LAPD. This relationship was essential, and would be a major cause for the shift in how the police were portrayed in movies and television.
This shift set the stage for Dragnet. By the 1950's, this radio turned television series was the highest watched shows in America, which ran on authenticity. The opening monologue would state, "the story you are about to see is true." This could be said because the LAPD had a hand in making the script, which in turn allowed them to approve and disapprove what was being aired. The influence of the LAPD made it so they could portray a very specific image of the police. Highlighting the good things, and leaving out problematic details. Dragnet also focused on police and their sanitization, and little on any information about the criminals.
However, this was not the only show on the air (just one of the most popular). One more liberal leaning show, Naked City dived into who criminals were and took a step back from militaristic policing. Yet, the show would still perpetuate myths of police. Some instances that they would be cool, calm, and collective even in active shooter situations.
Each of these early positive portraying police shows created thematic pillars in which following police shows have built. Major themes include: "cops are inherently good, criminals are inherently evil, crime is real and it is coming for you, and cops fix everything." While these themes are not visible in every police show we see today (maybe part to the branching out the genre has taken), this idea is concrete due to the image created in these early shows.
Due to these ideologies that are burned into the mass populations mind, many police shows began to 'rethink' their message after the death of George Floyd and throughout the summer of 2020. Many called an end of the 'good cop' trope in media. For example, the popular television show COPS was postponed after 25 years of being on air. Brooklyn Nine-Nine, a popular comedic take on policing, announced to take a step back, reconsider, and even 'trash' some episodes in the works. Even the children's show PAW PATROL came under fire in mass media.
This acknowledgement is a major turning point. For the general population and television stations to be conscious of the affect police shows has on the perspectives of police is a major step to remove a rose covered lens. It is important to portray a mix of problematic practices, as well as the good practices of policing to show the most accurate picture of police.
References:
Comments
Post a Comment